Your Favorites. Every Month. Automatically.
Subscribe to your go-to BFY products and never think about reordering. Save 10% on every delivery, skip or pause whenever you need to, and cancel anytime — no hoops.
How It Works
-
1. Pick Your Products
Choose from our baking mixes, cookies, and protein products. Select the flavors you love — or try something new each month.
-
2. Set Your Frequency
Deliveries go out monthly. You'll be charged automatically before each shipment — no surprises, just your favorites showing up on schedule.
-
3. We Ship, You Enjoy
Your order ships anywhere in the US. Manage everything — swap products, skip a month, pause, or cancel — from your account portal.
Why Subscribe
-
Save 10% on Every Order
Subscribers get 10% off every shipment — automatically applied, no code needed.
-
Full Control, Always
Skip a month, pause your subscription, swap products, or cancel — all from your account. No phone calls, no hassle.
-
Ships Anywhere in the US
We ship nationwide. Your subscription arrives on schedule whether you're in California or New York.
Subscription Questions
Common Questions
What products are available as subscriptions?
Baking mixes, cookies, and select protein products are available on subscription. Browse the full selection in our Subscribe & Save collection.
How much do I save with a subscription?
Subscribers save 10% on every order compared to one-time purchase pricing. The discount is applied automatically at checkout — no code needed.
When will I be charged?
You'll be charged when your subscription order is processed each month. You'll receive an email reminder before each charge so you have time to make any changes.
Can I change what's in my subscription?
Yes — log in to your account and visit the subscription portal to swap products, change quantities, or update your delivery address before your next charge date.
How do I skip, pause, or cancel?
Log in to your account → go to Subscriptions → and choose Skip, Pause, or Cancel. You're always in control. No penalties, no questions asked.
Can I have multiple subscriptions?
Yes — you can subscribe to multiple products and manage them all from the same account portal.
Ready to Never Run Out?
Pick your products, set it, and forget it. Your favorites show up every month — and you save every time.